H

Franke × van den Dorpel — Vectors, Apple Munich (2026)

Curatorial text by Margit Rosen, Head of Collections, Archives & Research at ZKM, Karlsruhe. Event: Vectors (VO'26 Special), Various Others, Munich, 14–24 May 2026. Site: Apple, Karlstrasse, Munich. Source: Herbert W. Franke & Harm van den Dorpel (German text, English translation, works list, the artist's Instagram post).

The pairing

Herbert W. Franke, Move (Blockade): rows of repeated coloured units on black
Herbert W. Franke, Move (Blockade) (1991–94), IBM PC compatible, Quick BASIC 4.5

On a black screen, a wide rectangle of repeated square units in rows: orange and brown, white, pink, red, grey, violet and blue blocks, edged with an orange-brown border.

Vectors was a special programme of Various Others that placed art in Munich company sites, among them Apple, the BMW Foundation, Bayerischer Rundfunk and the Deutsches Museum's Forum der Zukunft, with seven curators. Rosen curated the presentation at Apple's research and development site on Karlstrasse, which her text describes as part of Apple's European Chip Design Center: "More than 2,000 engineers work here and at further Apple locations in Munich and Bavaria" on chip design, power management and wireless technologies.

The artist's post on the installation describes Stained Unravel (Blockade) as "installed alongside Herbert W. Franke's historical computers" and says: "My work (image 1–3) takes its cues from his CRT palette and square-patterned grids (image 4)." Image 4 is the frame of Move (Blockade) above. That is the only Franke work the Vectors sources name; which other works were shown, and on which machines, is not recorded. A second Franke work, printed on the covers of a computer-art yearbook in 1981, is compared with van den Dorpel's Swallow, Only Shallow below, under The photograph as data.

Blockade is the eighth token of Stained Unravel. Its on-chain description counts the edition as "7 + 1 MP tokens" and calls Blockade a Museum Proof, "a commissioned work made in response to Herbert W. Franke's Move (Blockade) (1991–94). First shown inside Apple's European Chip Design Center, curated by Margit Rosen" (token data). Its title repeats Franke's.

Franke, as Rosen introduces him

Herbert W. Franke (1927–2022), a physicist who also wrote science fiction and explored caves, "was one of the first theorists worldwide to formulate the idea that the computer could be an artistic medium", Rosen writes. In the early 1980s he began working on an Apple II. His programs, "often fewer than thirty lines long", generate moving structures of lines and colour fields. "The limited colour palette, the slow drawing speed, and the moiré effect of the CRT monitor were not obstacles for Franke but became the material of a new pictorial language. He was interested in how visual complexity — or even beauty — could emerge from mathematical rules."

Franke's own essay in the yearbook Computer Graphics and Art for 1980–81 already treats moiré as material: "a means of design of a special sort", a "supersign" that stays recognisable when its lines are too close for the eye to separate (digest, p. 33).

Move (Blockade), the work Blockade answers, is later than those Apple II programs: a QuickBASIC program for the IBM PC, dated 1991–94 in the works list (harm.work's token listing gives 1991).

What Blockade takes from Franke

Blockade runs the engine of the whole series: shapes set by exact neighbour positions, colour that shifts while a cell rests, touching cells merged into groups (→ Stained Unravel). Its program differs from the other seven tokens in palette, rules and timing, and two of those differences follow the artist's two cues.

Palette. Black ground and nine gradients. One of them starts on rgb(0,0,170), the blue of the IBM PC's 16-colour palette, the machine Move (Blockade) was written for. Beside Franke's frame the palette shares black, orange and brown, white, magenta and that blue, and adds a green.

Grid. Blockade uses a closed pool of 18 curated rule-sets and never a random one. Eight of the 18 belong to no other token, and four of those carry Franke's first name in the code: Herb Cube 1, Herb Cube 2, Herb xj and herb switch. In the eight, almost two thirds of the cell kinds named are the full square, so whole squares spread across the field at fixed spacings. The square-patterned grid the artist names as a cue is written into the rules. Timing and the full palette are on the Stained Unravel page.

Stained Unravel (Blockade), frame: dense coloured field on black with a green zone lower right
Stained Unravel (Blockade) (2026), frame

A dense field on black. A band of small dotted cells runs along the top; long horizontal streaks of orange, blue, magenta and white cross the middle; the lower right is dominated by green.

Stained Unravel (Blockade), frame: long diagonal strokes in blue, magenta and violet
Stained Unravel (Blockade) (2026), frame

Long strokes in blue, magenta and violet run from lower left to upper right across most of the frame. In the lower left, vertical columns of mixed colours stand over a chequered patch.

Beauty and ageing

Rosen's text turns on one distinction (quoted from the English translation in the source):

Where Franke sought to make the beauty of mathematics visible, van den Dorpel is interested in the moment a system reaches its limit — and what unfolds from there. Colour functions as memory: it indicates how long a state holds before being displaced by the next. The image ages according to rules it does not conceal.

The first and last of these sentences adapt the April 2026 draft text on Stained Unravel, which has "where Franke sought to make the beauty of mathematics visible, Van den Dorpel is interested in its aging" and "It ages, visibly, according to laws it does not conceal" (draft). The distinction predates Rosen's text.

She also names what they share: "Franke and van den Dorpel both work in rule-systems — and in the moment when something emerges from computation that escapes control."

Read as a table, which is the wiki's arrangement rather than Rosen's:

Frankevan den Dorpel
What the rule is forthe form it producesthe point where it is exhausted and replaced
Colourhue of the drawn fieldrecord of how long a cell has kept its shape
Timethe new overwrites the olda state shows its age until it is displaced

The Time row comes from Franke himself. His essay in the 1980–81 yearbook describes his program Mondrian, "which begets series of pictures in any desired length, whereby anterior elements are over-written by the new" (yearbook, p. 32). His pictures were displaced too, so displacement alone does not separate the two practices; Stained Unravel adds the age of each state.

The mechanism behind "colour functions as memory" is the staining rule of 3000: a cell counts the iterations since it last changed, and its colour moves from a start to an end colour while it stays the same. On Franke's screens colour belongs to what is drawn; in Stained Unravel it belongs to the cell's history. Process Legibility puts the same difference as a difference of time span: Franke's image is judged at the moment of looking, Stained Unravel over many iterations. The palette that returns across van den Dorpel's works since 2004 is memory at a longer scale (→ The Markov's Dream Palette); Blockade is the one token whose palette takes its cue from another artist's screen.

The grid and the loom

The Senescenence press release places the series in a line "from the binary logic of the weaving loom, to early two-dimensional pixel graphics, to the contemporary GPU" (press release). It does not mention Franke. In the wiki's reading, Blockade puts a name to the middle term: Franke's square-patterned screens are the pixel graphics between the loom and the GPU. The grid's longer history in the practice is on The Grid.

The photograph as data (1980–81)

Rosen's text names one Franke work. A second comes closer to van den Dorpel's practice: Transformation, Anton Bruckner, printed on both covers of Computer Graphics and Art, the yearbook for 1980–1981 edited by Grace C. Hertlein, on the theme "Mathematics and Computer Art" (digest). The contents page describes it: "A photograph of the composer is input as data for computer transformation in a series of very different generative works, resulting in Surrealistic compositions, front and back covers." The sitter is Anton Bruckner; the back cover is "Illustration two in the series".

Computer Graphics and Art yearbook 1980–1981, front cover: Franke's Bruckner portrait in grey contour bands
Herbert W. Franke, Transformation, Anton Bruckner, front cover of Computer Graphics and Art, Yearbook 1980–1981

An old man's face fills the frame in a few greys on a coarse square raster, and every boundary between two greys is a staircase of pixels. Around the eye sockets, the nose and the mouth, where the photograph's tone changes fast, the boundaries crowd into thin stripes that run light, dark, light again. Across the cheeks and the background they open into wide patches. The face stays legible, but only just.

The yearbook does not say how the series was made. Franke's essay in the same issue, "Mathematics and Computer Art", describes the means without naming the cover. "Picture processing" answers the critics who thought computer graphics "confined to non-representational statements": with it "pictures may be estranged and quite new effects won for the abstraction" (p. 30). A picture is a matrix, "a digital numbers-field", and with enough rows and columns "real objects too may be delineated" (p. 38). Its greys can be assigned "module-n", so that values receive "the same grayness or color when they have the same positive difference in relation to a multiple of n" (p. 33). Under such a coding a grey returns every n steps, and a steep slope of tone becomes a run of stripes. That is what the cover shows. The yearbook does not name the operation; van den Dorpel, who uses the same one, reads the cover this way (below).

Back cover: the Bruckner portrait in checkerboards and dot grids, with concentric rings
Herbert W. Franke, Transformation, Anton Bruckner, illustration two, back cover of the same yearbook

The back cover runs the same portrait through other rules. Face and ground are filled with checkerboards and dot grids of several sizes, so that parts of one face seem drawn at different resolutions. Concentric rings are laid over the picture, one beside the nose and one at the collar, with nothing in the face to account for them. They look like the moiré Franke calls "a means of design of a special sort" (p. 33).

A Man and Blow Out

Swallow, Only Shallow (2024) was made with a tool the artist wrote in December 2023 beside Struggle for Pleasure, a branch of the same code that he called the pixelator (process notes). harm.work describes the change: "instead of making the decisions of which pixel operation to employ, or how to calculate the next colour in a geometric generative fashion, I fed it existing found images." The code bears this out. The Struggle for Pleasure generator chooses each operation with a Markov chain and each colour from a palette. The pixelator decides nothing about colour. It draws the photograph into a hidden canvas and fills the visible square with the average colour of the whole picture. Then it splits squares into four, a few at a time and partly at random, and fills each new cell with the average of the pixels beneath it, until a cell is a thousandth of the side. The picture arrives from coarse to fine. Depending on the order of splitting, which changed between versions, it also arrives unevenly: one region can be resolved while another is still a few large blocks. The first version, of 19 December 2023, did the same in order, drawing the whole picture at 1 × 1 cells, then 2 × 2, 4 × 4 and so on to 1024 × 1024, one level a second.

This is the matrix passage of Franke's essay run as a process: "If one uses matrices with a sufficient number of lines and columns, then with their help real objects too may be delineated in a corresponding degree of fineness" (p. 38). The pixelator shows the way from too few lines and columns to enough, and the photograph is "input as data" in the sense of Franke's caption.

The pictures are frames from early-1990s concert films, music videos and television interviews, captured from the screen on 17 December 2023; the artist calls them "video stills from that era" (Verse, 2024). States of the process were saved from the browser at 8192 pixels on 2 and 3 February 2024. The colours were set at the end in Photoshop, with one Hue/Saturation and one Levels adjustment and nothing else.

Blow Out: a head-sized oval of marbled orange, cyan and violet bands among flat coloured blocks
Blow Out (2024), Swallow, only Shallow, NFT

Blow Out comes from a television interview: a long-haired, bearded man seen from the front, in a printed T-shirt. The large oval left of centre is his head and hair, the narrower violet oval down its middle his face, and the rounded block at the bottom the print on his shirt. The earliest saved state is a coarse field of blue and violet blocks in which the head can be read; the later states are green and blue, and the final orange and cyan come from the hue shift. Around the head the ground breaks into flat blocks, large at the upper right and small near the form. Of the twelve works this is the closest to Franke's front cover: a musician's head and shoulders, frontal, filling the square, turned into bands that crowd where the picture changes fast. Across a slope the colours come round again, orange, cyan, violet, orange, instead of running once from dark to light.

A Man: a standing figure in dripping violet bands, ringed oval spots, olive and green blocks
A Man (2024), Swallow, only Shallow, NFT

A Man began as a blue and green image, saved under the same name as stills of a singer at a microphone; which frame it comes from is not settled. A standing figure at the right is drawn in dripping bands of violet, pink and grey. Three oval spots, at the left edge, in the centre and at the right, are each ringed by iridescent bands, the nearest thing in the series to the rings on Franke's back cover. There the rings are laid over the face; here they close around spots in the picture. Four saved states show the pixelator at work: in the first the figure is still a column of coarse coloured blocks while the rest of the picture is already fine, and by the fourth it is resolved.

The bands come from overflow. Averaging alone cannot make them: each cell takes the mean of what lies under it, and no mean turns a slope of tone into repeated stripes. The artist explains (November 2026): "Once a channel of a colour exceeds its maximum value of 255, it overflows to zero again. This is what Herbert did, and also what I did. This is what creates the psychedelic colour banding." A channel that runs past 255 and starts again at 0 is counted modulo 256, which is Franke's module-n coding with n = 256. Franke's cover has one grey channel, so a slope of tone becomes light, dark, light again. A colour has three channels, and red, green and blue each wrap at their own point, so in the series a slope becomes a cycle of hues; the hue shift at the end turns the whole cycle. In the files the wrap comes before the pixelator's last pass: the bands are already there in A Man's first saved state and in a banded still kept with the working files, while the pixelator code only averages.

The pixelator's share is the grid, and there the two differ. Franke's raster is uniform, and the textures of his back cover are patterns drawn on one grid. The pixelator's grid is uneven, because cells split in a partly random order, so a state taken mid-process keeps large blocks in some places and fine cells in others (→ Algorithmic Archaeology, under 1974 — the quadtree). Van den Dorpel did not know the Bruckner images when he made the series; he found the yearbook in November 2026. He calls the series "a key example of a discovery made as part of algorithmic archaeology" (→ Algorithmic Archaeology, under Recognition).

Both start from music. Franke took the portrait of a composer. The series takes stills from a genre in which, the artist says in the same talk, "the band is there only to supply signals for this half heavy signal processing chain". The files show such a chain for pictures: a screen capture, colour values pushed past their maximum so that they wrap, the pixelator, a hue shift.

Agent's reading: the photograph as signal

Thesis. Rosen: "Where Franke sought to make the beauty of mathematics visible, van den Dorpel is interested in the moment a system reaches its limit." The table above files Franke's rule under the form it produces.

Antithesis. Transformation, Anton Bruckner starts from a photograph, and Franke's essay gives picture processing the aim of estrangement. The front cover stops where the face is barely legible, at the limit Rosen reserves for van den Dorpel.

Synthesis. In both artists' photographic works the photograph is only a source of numbers for a rule. Rosen's distinction still holds, but as a difference in what each series keeps fixed. Franke keeps one photograph and changes the rule: the two covers are two of "a series of very different generative works" made from one portrait, and his essay says that in a series the invariants "prove to be the stylistic elements" while the parameters change (p. 31). Swallow, Only Shallow keeps one rule and changes the photograph: each time the pixelator page loads, it picks a picture at random from a list and runs the same procedure on it, and the twelve works are "processed images from metal, grunge & shoegaze memories" (harm.work). So Rosen's "beauty against limit" fits Move (Blockade) beside Stained Unravel. Between Bruckner and Swallow, Only Shallow the operation is the same, values that wrap past a maximum, found independently four decades apart; what differs is which term of the series stays fixed.

See also