left gallery (2015–2022)
left gallery sold files. The file was the object, in whatever format the work happened to be: .app, .exe, .saver, .html, .gif, .mp4, .epub, .mobi, .txt, .rtf, .m3u. Its own phrase for what it produced and sold was downloadable objects, and Paloma Rodríguez Carrington meant the noun literally:
We don't perceive these works as purely digital or virtual; they are actual objects, hence "downloadable objects."
Van den Dorpel co-founded it in Berlin in 2015 with Rodríguez Carrington, an anthropologist and his partner, and the interface was designed with Beautiful Company. It closed in March 2022 (harm.work). Danni Shen's Rhizome profile of January 2018 calls it "the first to directly employ Bitcoin and blockchain technology" and describes a UI with the feel of "an app store that meets contemporary art gallery"; harm.work calls it "one of the earliest proto-NFT marketplaces, opening two years before the ERC-721 standard." The artists it published included Damon Zucconi, Rafaël Rozendaal, Viktor Timofeev, William Kherbek, Dorine van Meel, Gene McHugh, Ryan Kuo and Adriana Ramić.
In 2019 the gallery showed in a building. For rite of access at Stroom Den Haag the works ran on monitors set on long plywood tables with green tops, with headphones beside them and yellow exercise balls on the floor. The window lettering ends "…e sell files", above the address stroom.left.gallery.
The occasion
The gallery grew out of one sale. In 2015 van den Dorpel was invited by Cointemporary, an online platform run from Vienna, to an event at the MAK, Vienna's Museum of Applied Arts. In April 2015 the museum bought 20 of the 100 editions of Event Listeners (2015), a generative macOS screensaver of Lindenmayer-system branchings (→ Event Listeners), and paid in Bitcoin; the editions had been minted through ascribe.io on the Bitcoin blockchain. His essay Tokenising Sustainability (2021) calls it "the first time a museum bought NFTs, and paid with a cryptocurrency"; Shen calls it "the first recorded occasion that an artwork was purchased by an institution using Bitcoin", and Tina Rivers Ryan, in Spike #70, "the first tokenised work ever purchased by a museum". After the purchase "all my 100 editions were sold to collectors and another museum", and "this unexpected success inspired my partner, Paloma Rodríguez Carrington, and me to start our own marketplace for blockchain ascribed artworks: left gallery." His fuller account of the sale is in the ZORA interview (→ Subdued Iconoclasm). Two months later the MAK showed the screensaver in its exhibition for the first Vienna Biennale (→ Vienna Biennale, 2015).
The problem behind it was older. Shen dates it to his student years, artificial intelligence at the Vrije Universiteit and then time-based arts at the Gerrit Rietveld Academie (→ 935), when he "first noticed the art world's lack of affinity for and indifference towards the curation and preservation of immaterial media."
What it did
Large, cheap editions. "Initially, left gallery offered relatively large editions of artworks for relatively low prices. For example, we would offer a work as an edition of one hundred, with each edition selling for fifty Euros," he told Ryan in Spike #70 (summary). Shen describes the target as "a generation acclimated to buying smartphone apps, icon packs, and subscriptions to software and streaming services", and the buyers as graphic designers, startup offices and collectors from tech and business. The editions were still limited: Shen notes the work was "made scarce on the web in order to sell exclusive, largely commissioned work". Later, he told Ryan, "the editions became smaller and more expensive, because the blockchain transaction costs per edition got so high".
Ownership registered outside the gallery. Editions were registered through ascribe.io, which wrote a certificate of authenticity and its timestamp onto the Bitcoin blockchain. Shen gives the reason: "If ascribe or left gallery cease to exist, that information will remain verifiable as long as the blockchain is around, since ascribe only offers the interface which places the work on the blockchain," and the system "allows the resale of editions independent of the gallery's interface, as opposed to other digital edition sites that vendor-lock work into their platforms."
Apps outside the app stores. Getting software onto a phone means an account with Apple or Google, which take a share of every sale (Shen gives 20%), and stores with no category for art. left gallery sold apps those stores would not carry. Van den Dorpel to Shen:
left gallery offers software so that the art can be interactive and generative. Not only using decentralized technology for ownership but also for payment, and calling it left gallery, is a political conviction. We have very limited means of opposition or rebellion, but generally, art has a very small but direct force.
Obsolescence handled per work. Shen records a pragmatic approach to conservation, with strategies chosen per project with the artist: when macOS stopped supporting a screensaver format, the software was recompiled with the artist. Selling the file instead of linking to it was itself an answer to what had happened to Club Internet, whose works were links to the artists' own servers, many now gone.
rite of access (Stroom Den Haag, 2019)
From 7 September to 20 October 2019 left gallery took over the exhibition space of Stroom Den Haag for left gallery: rite of access. It was the second guest of Stroom's programme Our House, your Home, which hands the space to international organisations; the first had been the Visual Culture Research Center from Kyiv. The curators were van den Dorpel, Emer M. Grant, who had curated E-State Realisms in Miami Beach the year before (→ E-State Realisms), and Lua Vollaard; Laurel Schwulst designed the exhibition (press release and works).
The press release made the token the condition of seeing the works:
in rite of access, this token mechanism creates the conditions to access the works on display: engagement of visitors, such as purchases and social media activity operate as a stream of credit, which allow the works to remain on view. follow left gallery on twitter or subscribe to the mailinglist, and the time to see the complete works increases; unlike its pages, and access may be denied. a purchase made through left gallery anywhere in the world extends the display of the works at stroom den haag.
A public institution, open to anyone who walks in, became a room where the works stayed on view only as long as sales and followers anywhere in the world kept up the credit. The release gives the purpose: "by guaranteeing the artificial scarcity of objects in their portfolio, left gallery seeks to uncover the invisible degrees of access that are encoded in consuming art in a public institution". The room was also a showroom. It "operates as a 'serving suggestion', showing how the works could be installed in a domestic setting once purchased", which explains the furniture: plywood tables, headphones, exercise balls to sit on.
The works were "screensavers, a flight simulator, ebooks, an alarm clock, apps, merch, and an AI assistant", part from the gallery's catalogue and part commissioned for the show. The collection page lists Adriana Ramić's bubamara ocr (an app and a poster), Ryan Kuo's faith, Dorine van Meel's video beyond the nation state, Viktor Timofeev's twodom, Micah Schippa's screensaver calendars.earth, the audio playlist retrodiction by William Kherbek, a flight simulator by Laurel Schwulst and Soft, and posters by Simon Denny (amazon worker cage) and Omsk Social Club (extended youth). Van den Dorpel's own contributions were the poster Merch Clouds, an aerial photograph of fields under a cloud printed on archival paper, "inspired by a design by Laurel Schwulst" (→ Small Collections), and oracle alarm, a phone app made with Schwulst and Soft, which the release's "alarm clock" refers to. The "AI assistant" was his as well (the artist, November 2026).
The exhibition came a year after Proof of Work at the Schinkel Pavillon, where left gallery had explained its tokens in an animated lecture and van den Dorpel had acted as one of the curatorial "nodes" (→ Proof of Work), and a year before the relaunch that moved ownership into a database. At Stroom the token decided whether the works could be seen.
The blockchain soul, and losing it
Ascribe stopped offering its service around 2017, and the record it had written became hard to reach: "Although the token provenance information that ascribe stored on the immutable Bitcoin blockchain will always remain there, in practice, we have lost access to it". Van den Dorpel moved the registry to Ethereum: "in 2018, I bit the bullet, deployed an ERC721 smart contract and minted Ethereum tokens for the editions that had been sold," so that "some editions were now tokenized on two blockchains at once." His are.na channel Token UX, opened on 7 November 2018 with the description "Crypto Tokens (intended for NFT)", dates the result. On 10 November he saved tokens.left.gallery to it as an "overview of all left gallery tokens" (block 3015712), and on 25 November a screenshot of the page.
Each edition is a numbered circle. Editions with a named collector are drawn larger, in white: editions 1 and 3 of Adriana Ramić's bubamara ocr (2018) belong to Paloma Rodríguez Carrington and Aleksandra Domanović, and edition 1 links to its token on Etherscan. Buyers were less interested than the screenshot suggests: "few buyers actually requested the token belonging to their purchase."
In the same year he was weighing the technology in public. On 11 April 2018 he opened an are.na channel titled I want to believe and filed the Rhizome profile and Spike's notice of the gallery's 2016 launch (1, 2) beside Kai Stinchcombe's essay "Blockchain is not only crappy technology but a bad vision for the future" (block) and Nicholas Weaver's lecture Burn It With Fire (block). In May he uploaded the paper "Bitcoin as Politics: Distributed Right-Wing Extremism" (block). In October he added two peer-to-peer tools that run without a chain, Micro.blog and the Beaker browser, whose tagline reads "Peer-to-peer Web browser. No blockchain required." (1, 2).
The essay gives two reasons the Ethereum link did not survive. Interest in the tokens kept falling while transaction costs rose "to a degree where the costs for minting and transferring tokens exceeded the sales price of the actual artworks by orders of magnitude". Then, for the 2020 relaunch, built from scratch during the pandemic: "As only a few buyers in the previous years had shown interest in owning an NFT for their purchase, I hesitated to implement an integration with the Ethereum blockchain again." Ownership moved into an ordinary database.
I was proud of what we had achieved with the left gallery relaunch, and I was amazed by all the works that artists offered on it, but also it hurt, because left gallery had lost some of its "blockchain soul".
During the rebuild he designed a registry of his own. From 3 August to 7 September 2020 he kept notes in the are.na channel left registry. One defines the parties: "A person is either an artist, an owner, or both. When an artist creates a new work of art, they are both. When they sell it, they cease to own it, but remain the creator. Only an owner can destroy their property." (block 8213283). Another lists the metadata a file needs, among them the edition ("X + Y AP / unlimited"), a public URL on "http(s), IPFS, DAT", the current owner and, for software, the "ideal hardware to run software on" (block 8213166). A third sketches the keepers, messages and queries of a chain built with the Cosmos SDK (block 8522341), whose NFT module he collected in a separate channel on 26 August (Cosmos SDK NFT Implementation Design).
The data model he drew by 28 August joins that chain to a cataloguing standard: the Asset table types its owner and creator as Cosmos addresses (sdk.AccAddress) and adds the Dublin Core fields Contributor, Publisher, Type, Format, Date, Language, Subject and Description, which he had copied out on 12 August in a channel on Metadata Standards (block 8307915). What shipped was the database.
In the winter of 2021/22 he told Ryan that the gallery was "looking into the possibilities of using a different blockchain with lower transaction costs, which would allow us to sell, for example, e-books for a low price with an open edition number." In March 2022 it closed. For the essay's argument about records that stay on a chain while the means of reading them disappears, see Tokenising Sustainability (2021) and Mediation and the Archive.
The line from the surf clubs
Agent's reading: circulation, not stages
Thesis. This page and Surf Clubs used to tell the history as a sequence: a network (the surf clubs), a curated space (Club Internet), a market (left gallery), and finally the museum.
Antithesis. The dates run the other way. Van den Dorpel was in museum group shows from 2010 (Free at the New Museum, Maps & Legends at MACRO; → 935), while Club Internet was winding down. And the museum came before the market: the MAK's purchase of Event Listeners in April 2015 is what led to left gallery, by his own account.
Synthesis. What continues from the surf clubs is a question about how screen-made work circulates as files, and who can hold it. The clubs' answer, in Chris Coy's account, was everyone, for free, the moment it is online. Club Internet showed the same artists' work one piece at a time, with curators, run dates and a copyright line, but still as links to the artists' own servers. left gallery sold the file itself, in editions of a hundred, with a record of ownership the gallery did not control. Each answer came at the moment the question did, beside the institutions rather than before or after them. Damon Zucconi and Rafaël Rozendaal showed in both Club Internet and left gallery. The one thing left gallery reversed is the surf clubs' refusal of ownership; Dullaart's remark that their ethos was "almost the opposite of the current attitude towards the commodification of digital files as NFTs" names that distance. The reversal was already argued in a text that generation shared. Seth Price's "Dispersion" (2002), which van den Dorpel calls hugely influential on his early practice and which was the touchstone of Free, rejects "free of charge" as the test of public art and proposes to "take what's free and sell it back in a new package". It also names what the popular archive lacks, "cataloguing, provenance, and authenticity", the record left gallery wrote to a blockchain (→ Dispersion).
See also
- Surf Clubs — the network the practice started in
- Club Internet — the 2008–2010 online exhibition space
- Tokenising Sustainability (2021) — the essay: ascribe.io, the two blockchains, the lost blockchain soul
- Subdued Iconoclasm (ZORA, 2021) — his account of the Event Listeners sale
- Protocol, Taste, and Systems — protocol-attachment read through the same episode
- Mediation and the Archive — immutability versus accessibility
- Works Overview — Event Listeners and the wider catalogue
- Dispersion — Seth Price's essay: the copy disperses, the title is recorded