Club Internet (2008–2010)
Club Internet started as a domain speculation. Club Internet was a major telecom provider in France, so van den Dorpel bought the .org expecting to sell it on. He explained what happened next to Ceci Moss at Rhizome in October 2008:
But then I started playing with it and put a script online that enabled people to upload images. I got intrigued by the idea of forming a group of people like in a surfing club, with an exclusive and mysterious character found in societies like the Freemasons. Following that model, Club Internet is a society with membership, as well as being an online gallery.
A domain, an upload script, a society: the gallery came last, and it is what the fifteen recorded shows document. The first, First Selection, opened on 8 May 2008; the last record was created on 28 March 2010. Van den Dorpel's CVs give the run as 2008–2009 (→ 932, 935), and 932 calls the space "non-archived", which was true until its database was recovered. Paul Slocum's 2016 catalogue of artist clubs for Rhizome also gives 2008–2009 and counts 88 artists in 10 online exhibitions; the database records more.
What made it different from a surf club
Club Internet came out of the surf-club milieu (→ Surf Clubs), but it is not a surf club. A surf club is a flat group blog: every member posts, posts stack in one scroll, and there is no curator, run date or closing. Club Internet put a gallery apparatus around the same population of artists. Each show has a title, a curator, a from-date and a till-date, a header and footer for the press text, and a set of works attached to it. The interface showed one work at a time, framed in a fake browser chrome with an address bar and a wand-shaped refresh button, and advanced with a next button. A collapsible sidebar carried the credits.
The sidebar is the whole editorial apparatus: the show's premise in one line, the artist list, a link to the Wikipedia article on the KISS principle, a mailing-list signup, and "All works © by the artists". After Chris Coy's account in the Spike conversation of surf-club work belonging to everyone once online, that copyright line marks a difference.
The selection criterion was medium-specific. Asked what Free Fall was about, van den Dorpel answered first about where work belongs:
Works for Club Internet are chosen because they are best viewed online, rather than making a transformation from the screen to a video projector in a gallery. Television programs are best viewed at home, and not in a cinema, I believe the same often applies to Internet art.
Earlier shows, he said, "dealt with the subculture of internet artists or were referring to some (technical) knowledge usually available only to the more Internet aware visitors"; Free Fall was meant to need none of that, and the works "were suddenly floating in the air. There was no clear framework such as the browser or HTML to comment on."
The exhibition history
Fifteen shows survive in the shows table, built from the MySQL tables described under What happened to it. Shows 1 to 6 carry opening and closing dates; from show 7 the date fields are empty, so those are ordered by the timestamp on which the record was created.
Show 4 is missing from the table. Twenty-three works still point to it, all created in one evening (13–14 June 2008): twenty are van den Dorpel's, plus one each by Broskoski, Dullaart and Travis Hallenbeck. Their captions ("welcome", "Club Internet", "documentation of artworks", pages on aura, cybernetics and simulacrum) read as much like the site's own information pages as like a show. It never opened: Moss's October 2008 interview calls Free Fall, show 6, Club Internet's "fifth show".
Counts below are works and distinct exhibiting names as recorded. Collaborative entries (Daniel Eatock & Timothy Evans, Jeremy Hughes & Ken Seeno, Garrett Davis & Kieran Gillen, John Michael Boling & Guthrie Lonergan) count once, as the database stores them; two works with no author attached (International Klein Blue in show 1, fuck the sound in show 2) are left out of the artist counts.
2008
1 — First Selection. 8 May – 14 June 2008. Curated by Harm van den Dorpel. 42 works, 24 artists.
AIDS-3D, Charles Broskoski, Laura Brothers, Petra Cortright, Aleksandra Domanović, Harm van den Dorpel, Constant Dullaart, Daniel Eatock & Timothy Evans, Michael Guidetti, Travis Hallenbeck, JODI, Oliver Laric, Jan Robert Leegte, Guthrie Lonergan, Miltos Manetas, Ilia Ovechkin, Rafael Rozendaal, Will Simpson, Paul Slocum, Thomas Traum, Isaac Bigsby Trogdon, Anne de Vries, James Whipple, Damon Zucconi.
Thirteen of the twenty-four were Nasty Nets authors; Simpson and Ovechkin posted on Loshadka; the rest include the European contingent van den Dorpel knew from del.icio.us. Works included Rozendaal's colorflip.com, Laric's 787 Cliparts, Manetas' Jackson Pollock (2003) and van den Dorpel's bison.gif.
2 — ORACLE. 16 June – 12 July 2008. Curated by Harm van den Dorpel. 22 works, 18 artists.
AIDS-3D, Kari Altmann, Charles Broskoski, Carl Burgess, Jeff Carey, Chris Collins, Aleksandra Domanović, Harm van den Dorpel, Constant Dullaart, Joel Holmberg, INFObeard, Oliver Laric, Guthrie Lonergan, Ilia Ovechkin, Rafael Rozendaal, Travess Smalley, tntet, Damon Zucconi.
ORACLE is where van den Dorpel first showed Ethereal Self .com. INFObeard and tntet are pseudonyms; their member rows link to the Spirit Surfers blog.
3 — Contact (1997). 24 July – 20 August 2008. Curated by Damon Zucconi. 15 works, 14 artists.
Christopher Byler, Aleksandra Domanović, Harm van den Dorpel, Marcel Duchamp, Garrett Davis & Kieran Gillen, Nathan Hauenstein, Martijn Hendriks, KUO I-Chen, Hugh Pocock, Jordan Rhoat, Jeremy Hughes & Ken Seeno, Ken Seeno, Alexandr Skarlinski, James Whipple.
The first guest-curated show, named after Robert Zemeckis's film, with Duchamp's 3 Standard Stoppages included as a reenactment. Van den Dorpel's entry is recorded as Codec breeze, dated 2008, the year the artist gives for the Codec Breeze series (four videos; harm.work gives 2009).
5 — K.I.S.S. 29 August – 29 September 2008. Curated by Constant Dullaart. 28 works, 21 artists.
John Michael Boling, Victor Boulet, Mark Callahan, Ben Coonley, Petra Cortright, Chris Coy, Harm van den Dorpel, Constant Dullaart, Daniel Eatock, Yariv Alter Fin, Justin Kemp, Dennis Knopf, Stan L, Oliver Laric, Jan Robert Leegte, John Michael Boling & Guthrie Lonergan, David L. Mitchell, Jonathan Puckey, Rafael Rozendaal, Pascual Sisto, Ola Vasiljeva.
Keep It Simple, Stupid, the engineering maxim, used as a curatorial filter. Dullaart's own The internet says "no" was in it, as was his internet aesthetics copied to real life (nasty nets tribute), Laric's Touch My Body (Green Screen Version), and David L. Mitchell's a:hover { text-decoration: blink; } (2002), a work that is a CSS rule.
6 — Free Fall. 15 October – 15 November 2008. Curated by Harm van den Dorpel. 21 works, 18 artists.
Alain A-Dale, Kevin Bewersdorf, John Michael Boling, Jesper Carlsen, Harm van den Dorpel, Constant Dullaart, Azin Feizabadi, Michael Guidetti, Travis Hallenbeck, Martijn Hendriks, INFOpruner, Marcus Kaiser, Guthrie Lonergan, Barry Pearson, Rafael Rozendaal, Ken Seeno, Pascual Sisto, Damon Zucconi.
It opened with a party at Mediamatic in Amsterdam, which Moss reports as the first Club Internet show with "an 'official' opening event in a physical space". Van den Dorpel gave the title three readings: works with no browser or HTML left to comment on, falling through open air; "a Cheap Autumn", against the banking collapse then under way; and AIR, Adobe's platform for browserless web applications.
7 — Tag Team. Record created 14 November 2008. Organised by Guthrie Lonergan. 19 works, 14 artists.
John Michael Boling, Tyler Campbell, Petra Cortright, fixoid, Michael Guidetti, Travis Hallenbeck, Joel Holmberg, Lindsay Lawson, Olia Lialina, lowcast, Ilia Ovechkin, V/A, Jon Williams, Robert Wodzinski.
The show closest to a surf club. Lonergan's header and footer describe it: "Non-art" links from Club Internet members and others to sites by non-artists, among them Active SETI, Cougar Interactive, the Krannert Computing Center webcam at Purdue, pretty-secrets.net, Ulillillia City Software and WFTV 9 Orlando. Each entry credits an artist with the find, not the making. Six works are filed under V/A, with no finder named.
8 — Dissociation. Record created 22 November 2008. Curated by Harm van den Dorpel. 44 work rows, 24 artists.
Samuel Beckett, Charles Broskoski, Harm van den Dorpel, Constant Dullaart, Ida Ekblad, Thomas Galloway, JODI, Marc Kremers, Claire Legendre, Tobias Madison, Ilia Ovechkin, Christopher Pappas, Bradley Pitts, Poster Company, Seth Price, Jonathan Puckey, Rafael Rozendaal, Hayley A. Silverman, Pascual Sisto, Spectacular Society Corporation, Thomas Traum, V/A, Ola Vasiljeva, Damon Zucconi.
The record was edited well into 2009: many of its works are dated 2009, two are entered twice, and 25 of the 44 rows are switched off (active = 0), Seth Price's Dispersion (2008) among them; nineteen are active. No other show has more than two inactive rows, so the record looks like a working list rather than a fixed hang. Beckett's Quad (1981), active, sits beside Broskoski's .png paintings and two video stills by van den Dorpel captioned "from Dissociations" (2009). That caption shows the name in use before dissociations.com, which harm.work dates 2010 (932 gives 2011).
The Dispersion row is Price's essay of 2002. Entered on 10 June 2009, it links his PDF of 2008 at distributedhistory.com and a copy on Club Internet's own server, so the essay was filed in the show as a work. Van den Dorpel calls it hugely influential on his early practice; a year later it was the touchstone of Free at the New Museum, where both artists showed (→ Dispersion).
2009–2010
9 — Reverse Engineering: The Uncurated Reunion. Record created 7 March 2009. Curated by Harm van den Dorpel. 31 works, 29 artists.
Kari Altmann, Kevin Bewersdorf, Charles Broskoski, Laura Brothers, Mark Callahan, Chris Collins, Aleksandra Domanović, Constant Dullaart, Nathan Hauenstein, Martijn Hendriks, Joel Holmberg, Justin Kemp, Dennis Knopf, Marc Kremers, Oliver Laric, Jan Robert Leegte, Guthrie Lonergan, Miltos Manetas, Vadik Marmeladov, Tom Moody, Philipp Otto, Jon Rafman, Pascual Sisto, Alexandr Skarlinski, Travess Smalley, Thomas Traum, Ola Vasiljeva, Robert Wodzinski, Damon Zucconi.
Nearly one work per artist, thirty of them dated 2009 and nine titled Untitled. The subtitle is the method: submissions rather than selections, tied to LMIRL (Let's Meet In Real Life), the New York show it ran alongside at Capricious Gallery (→ 935). Rafman's contribution was Portrait of a netartist as a young man .com.
10 — Z-Index. Record created 13 April 2009. Curated by Harm van den Dorpel. 7 works, 7 artists.
Charles Broskoski, JODI, Tobias Madison, Hayley A. Silverman, Sounder2, Spectacular Society Corporation, Robert Wodzinski.
Named for the CSS property that decides which element sits in front. The works include JODI's GEO GOO and Sounder2's mpg meditation #3: Kazimir Malevich.
11 — New Wave. Record created 15 May 2009. Curated by Harm van den Dorpel. 9 works, 9 artists.
Petra Cortright, Harm van den Dorpel, Sinem Erkas, Elna Frederick, Martijn Hendriks, Parker Ito, Oliver Laric, Guthrie Lonergan, Pascual Sisto.
Shown at the Internet Pavilion of the 53rd Venice Biennale in 2009 (→ 935). Laric's Versions is in it, as is Parker Ito's Self Portrait in 3D.
12 — stolen. Record created 6 July 2009. Curated by Martijn Hendriks. No works recorded: the show exists as a row with a curator and a slug and nothing attached.
13 — Once Upon a Time in the West. Record created 24 November 2009. Curated by Domenico Quaranta. 15 works, 15 artists.
AIDS-3D, Michael Bell-Smith, Brida, Wayne Clements, Chris Coy, Florian Cramer, Harm van den Dorpel, James Houston, Les Liens Invisibles, Oliver Laric, Olia Lialina, Eilis McDonald, Rosa Menkman, Rafael Rozendaal, Math Wrath.
The one show curated by a critic and historian rather than an artist, and the roster changes accordingly: European net art and glitch (Menkman, Cramer, Les Liens Invisibles, Brida) beside the American surf-club names. The database spells the curator "Domenico Quarante"; the show header links to domenicoquaranta.com, so the name is corrected here.
14 — AFK sculpture park. Record created 1 January 2010. 8 works, 7 artists: Aleksandra Domanović, Harm van den Dorpel, Constant Dullaart, Joel Holmberg, Oliver Laric, Billy Rennekamp, Rafael Rozendaal.
The show itself ran outdoors at Atelierhof Kreuzberg, Berlin, from 18 to 26 September 2009, under a title that abbreviates Away From Keyboard. The database records van den Dorpel as curator, but VVORK's documentation page, which 932 links, credits AIDS-3D with curating it, and both CVs list it as a group show he was in (→ 932, 935). VVORK published ordinary photographs of every work, taken on 19 September 2009. Club Internet published the same works as coloured point clouds floating on black: no ground, no garden, the object reduced to the sample points of a 3D scan. The scans are one form of the show's documentation beside the photographs, and the online gallery chose them.
The scan of eBay Sun reads as a tanning bed, its shell and base picked out in scattered colour. Dullaart's other work in the show was eBay Pharaoh; both titles name the auction site the objects came from.
In VVORK's photograph, Texture Mapping is three cubes standing on a concrete floor, their faces covered with printed images of marbled stone and painterly textures. The title describes the object: texture mapping is the 3D-graphics operation of wrapping an image onto geometry, and the cubes do that in matter. The scan above shows one cube and a stack of two, their surfaces carried by loose colour samples. A year earlier van den Dorpel had told Rhizome that running Club Internet "awoke my longing for creating physical objects"; the sculptural line continues through the Assemblages (→ the sculpture page).
15 — progressive recesses. Record created 30 January 2010. Curated by Harm van den Dorpel. 3 works, 3 artists: Charles Broskoski, Chris Collins, Harm van den Dorpel.
16 — progressive recesses. Record created 28 March 2010. Curated by Charles Broskoski. 10 works, 9 artists: Charles Broskoski, Tony Cokes, Harm van den Dorpel, David Hockney, Joel Holmberg, Oliver Laric, Timur Si-Qin, V/A, Ola Vasiljeva.
The last two records share a title and were set up two months apart, the second handed to Broskoski. Its slug is the placeholder title_url and its description a bare <img> tag, so the record was probably left mid-edit. Hockney's iPhone Painting (2009) is in it: in the wiki's reading, the phone that Dullaart names as the end of the surf-club window turns up in the last Club Internet show as a painting tool.
The roster
The member table has 124 entries. Of those, 106 exhibited at least once. Eighteen were registered but never shown: Peter Baldes, J. G. Ballard, Manuel Bürger, Jon Burchmore, Hevanet, Shane Hope, INFOsembler, Robert Morris, Marisa Olson, Planet Dan, Angelo Plessas, Domenico Quaranta (registered as a curator), Johnny Rogers, Emanuel Rossetti, Ramsay Stirling, SuperCPU, Dirk Vis, Jordan Wolfson.
The list is not only living artists. Marcel Duchamp, Samuel Beckett and Robert Morris have member rows, as do a Flickr slideshow (Poster Company), four Spirit Surfers pseudonyms, and a placeholder called V/A for found material with no author. Membership was a slot in a database, and van den Dorpel used it for whatever needed attributing.
By number of shows: van den Dorpel 11; Oliver Laric 8; Rafael Rozendaal, Charles Broskoski and Constant Dullaart 7; Damon Zucconi, Aleksandra Domanović, Guthrie Lonergan, Joel Holmberg and Pascual Sisto 5; Petra Cortright, Ilia Ovechkin, Martijn Hendriks and Ola Vasiljeva 4.
What happened to it
The domain lapsed; in August 2026 clubinternet.org served a WordPress site about casino bonuses, and the shows are gone from the live web. What survives is in two places: Internet Archive snapshots of a handful of show pages, and the MySQL tables from the DreamHost server (member, shows and work), exported in August 2026 and kept at media/member.sql, media/shows.sql and media/work.sql. This page is built from those three tables, cross-checked against the archived pages, VVORK, and Moss's interview.
The work table stores its text as latin1 holding UTF-8, so a number of captions in the raw dump are mojibake and have been decoded here. Most works are not recoverable: they were links to work hosted on the artists' own servers, and many of those servers are gone.
See also
- Surf Clubs — the milieu Club Internet came out of and departed from
- left gallery — the gallery van den Dorpel co-founded in 2015, which sold the files rather than linking to them
- Codec Breeze — the series, of which a piece was shown in Contact (1997), 2008
- Mediation and the Archive — the work and its documentation
- Release Early, Release Often — the open-source stance the surf-club ethos ran on
- Dispersion — Seth Price's essay, filed as a work in Dissociation (2009)
- Spike #70 — Surf Clubs (2003–), by Charles Broskoski and Constant Dullaart — Dullaart and Broskoski on the period