H

Surf Clubs (2003–)

A surf club is a group blog where artists post what they find: images, links, videos, sounds, half-made things, stacked in one scroll, each post placed with some attention to the ones above it. Only members publish; anyone can comment. The name comes from the tagline of Nasty Nets, "internet surfing club". Paul Slocum's catalogue of the clubs for Rhizome (2016) describes the form as one that "catalogs oddities and minutiae of the internet with a certain kind of dry humor."

The start date is contested. Rhizome traces a lineage to 2003 and the group blogs around the artist Jimpunk (noblog, 544x378 WebTV, SCREENFULL), which it calls "a missing link between earlier net art like JODI and later surf and art clubs." Spike's editors use the same date for the conversation between Charles Broskoski and Constant Dullaart that this page draws on, Surf Clubs (2003–) (Spike #70, Winter 2021/22). The form itself starts in 2006, when Nasty Nets and Supercentral launched.

Why it happened then

Dullaart dates the window by its technology:

Surf clubs blossomed after Google Images launched in 2001, but before the iPhone came in 2007 and using smartphones for media distribution became mainstream. Facebook only started to accept signups outside of US universities on 26 September, 2006.

He adds that Blogger and WordPress were gaining traction. Slocum's catalogue names the other conditions: hosting that ran PHP and MySQL as standard, "the expiration of the animated GIF patents, and the launch of user-friendly media sharing sites like Flickr, Delicious, and Youtube." There was a great deal of media and no personalised feed deciding what anyone should see. Broskoski calls the result a Goldilocks zone:

There was a ton of content – not so much as overwhelming as today – and most of it tended to be pretty weird, or at least it was way easier to get to the weirder territories. Because of this, people were truly digging for the things that resonated with them.

His analogy is the thrift store: "It's not just about finding the diamond in the rough, but finding the thing that was important to you, to your own ongoing practice." What has since been lost, in his account, is friction: people are now "served content that platforms think they might be interested in rather than having to find content on their own".

Meeting on del.icio.us

Both men describe meeting their peers through social bookmarking as much as through the blogs. Dullaart:

I remember posting in 2006 to the weblog Squeakyfrom run by Hamy Caldwell and me. Harm van den Dorpel joined it briefly and later turned me on to the social bookmarking service del.icio.us, and I got to see all these people who had found posts on the blog I made, and had tagged my homepage. There was an instant sense of community when I got to see their online works and bookmarks. I remember seeing Petra Cortright bookmarking her dentist.

Broskoski came to del.icio.us through Cory Arcangel's class at Parsons, found the tagging corny and tagged his early bookmarks unhelpfully on purpose; the network came later. "I met John Michael Boling through del.icio.us and he's been one of my best friends ever since." On the European side:

I have vague recollections of coming across some of our European friends on del.icio.us, Harm van den Dorpel, Aleksandra Domanović, Jan Robert Leegte, Ola Vasiljeva.

He also describes attempts to make some of that activity "more formal than the rest of the casual bookmarking that went on – trying to figure out where the line was between research and Curation (with a capital C)." In the wiki's reading, Club Internet was van den Dorpel's answer to that question and Are.na was Broskoski's.

The clubs

Nasty Nets, July 2007
Nasty Nets in July 2007, as archived by the Internet Archive. The sidebar carries the tagline "internet surfing club," a member count, the archive months, and the club's shared del.icio.us network feed.

Nasty Nets (2006–2012, nastynets.com) coined the term. Rhizome counts 1,360 posts by 39 authors and judges that "to some extent this is the blog that defined the surf club form." Rhizome and the New Museum released a Nasty Nets DVD in 2008, with cover artwork by Javier Morales, and the club had an installation and screening at the 2009 Sundance Film Festival. Its founders were John Michael Boling, Joel Holmberg, Guthrie Lonergan and Marisa Olson. The authors, by post count: Travis Hallenbeck, Tom Moody, Marisa Olson, Joel Holmberg, Guthrie Lonergan, John Michael Boling, Camille Paloque-Berges, Javier Morales, Robert Wodzinski, Petra Cortright, Olia Lialina, Paul Slocum, Michael Bell-Smith, Constant Dullaart, Peter Baldes, Kevin Bewersdorf, Pascual Sisto, Chris Coy, Brian Blomerth, Damon Zucconi, Dennis Knopf, Britta Gustafson, Brenna Murphy, Aleksandra Domanović, James Whipple, Kari Altmann, Michael Guidetti, Jan Robert Leegte, Ethan Hayes-Chute, Charles Broskoski, Dragan Espenschied, Charles Westerman, Paul B. Davis, Harm van den Dorpel, Emma Davenport, Laura Brothers, Chance Jackson, Summer Shiffman, Jordan Wolfson.

Supercentral, August 2007
Supercentral in August 2007. Each post takes its own full-bleed colour field; the right column lists authors by post count and offers a "browse by color" index.

Supercentral (2006–2010, supercentral.org) began in 2001 as Broskoski's homepage and a forum about skateboarding; in 2006 he turned it into a series of group blogs. Rhizome reads the path as typical: artists "started off using homepages and online communities for non-internet cultural interests (often music), and then gradually shifted their interest to internet and computer culture itself." It had 2,389 posts by 23 authors, the most of any surf club in the catalogue: Charles Broskoski, Chris Pappas, Tommy McCutcheon, Ben Ellis, Brandon Brown, Willis Elkins, Scott Schwartz, Pete Dahlberg, Emily Grenader, Nate Boley, Jessica Williams, Claire Evans, James Whipple, Damon Zucconi, yarr, Will Macfayden, Robin Willis, Seneca Garcia, Ben Dahlberg, John Michael Boling, Eli Bock, Travis Hallenbeck, Veronica Ortuno. Broskoski, its webmaster, later co-founded Are.na with John Michael Boling, Stuart Moore, Daniel Pianetti, Chris Sherron, Dena Yago and Damon Zucconi. Rhizome notes that "most of the founders of Are.na were previously founders or participants of surf clubs" and that Are.na can be used "as a replacement for centralized link services like Delicious". Van den Dorpel still uses it.

Spirit Surfers
Spirit Surfers, still posting. Each post sits in a box frame and can be split into two stacked panes, the "boon" and the "wake."

Spirit Surfers (2008–, spiritsurfers.net), founded by Kevin Bewersdorf and Paul Slocum, is one of the clubs still active, and the one with a form of its own. Rhizome describes its theme as "comic spirituality" and says the boon and the wake "are ambiguous and have been interpreted many different ways" by the members. Dullaart's reading:

I understood this as the difference between the thing of beauty that was found online while surfing – an image or a bit of information – and the journey towards a thing. In my eyes, it enabled thinking about an entire conversation as an artwork, instead of a single argument, piece or comment.

Rhizome lists 833 posts and gives the number of authors as 17, but names 18: Kevin Bewersdorf, Paul Slocum, Marcin Ramocki, Ethan Hayes-Chute, John Transue, Luke Murphy, Krist Wood, Aron Namenwirth, Harm van den Dorpel, Dragan Espenschied, Travis Hallenbeck, Olia Lialina, Peter Wilson, Patrick Armstrong, Patrick Groth, Peter Blasser, Chad Hopper, Rachel Abelson. Four Club Internet member rows point to spiritsurfers.net under pseudonyms: INFObeard, INFOpruner, INFOsembler and tntet.

The other clubs in Rhizome's catalogue are Double Happiness (2007–2015), Loshadka (2007–2013), Mouse Safari (2007–2011) and You Had Better Know (2008–2010). Several Loshadka authors (Billy Rennekamp, Will Simpson, Ilia Ovechkin, Travess Smalley, Thomas Galloway, Hayley A. Silverman) and Mouse Safari authors (Parker Ito, Justin Kemp, Eilis McDonald) recur in the Club Internet programme.

Club Internet itself (2008–2010) was van den Dorpel's own and was not a surf club: it had curators, run dates and one work on screen at a time (→ Club Internet). Dullaart's Spike biography calls him "curator for Club Internet".

The clubs met in a room at least once, at The Great Internet Sleepover at Eyebeam, New York, on 24 August 2007. Bennett Williamson of Double Happiness organised it; members of Nasty Nets, Supercentral, Double Happiness and Loshadka came, as did future founders of Are.na and of the art club R-U-In?s. Rhizome describes much of the time going on "showing off ideas and software like a programmer demoscene meetup."

Common property, and the gallery

Dullaart recalls Rhizome archiving Nasty Nets against hacking ("which happened") or a lapsed domain, and asking whether the members minded. He remembers Chris Coy's answer:

I remember Chris Coy [seecoy] saying that all the work had been posted with the understanding that it would belong to everyone as soon as it was online, and everyone could do with it whatever they wanted – almost the opposite of the current attitude towards the commodification of digital files as NFTs.

Broskoski traces the attitude to file sharing: "We are taking things from people, so we expect people to take things from us. A real abundance mindset." The open-source phrase van den Dorpel used as an exhibition title in 2013 comes from the same culture (→ Release Early, Release Often).

A second position dissolved faster. Broskoski:

There was definitely a time immediately prior where there was a kind of political stance – or at least I felt like this – that showing in a gallery or physical space was degrading and an inevitable mistranslation of the work, which was ideally meant to be seen by someone in their bedroom at 2 a.m. with a million other browser tabs open. The whole premise was that a work should be stumbled upon.

By 2009 the same artists were showing in rooms. Dullaart curated two Amsterdam shows that year: one built from artists' del.icio.us bookmarks, showing research and finished work on the same footing, and Versions, at NiMK with Annet Dekker and Petra Heck, which took the comment as a medium. Van den Dorpel was in Versions (→ 932, 935). Club Internet's Free Fall had opened with a party at Mediamatic, Amsterdam, in October 2008, and in September 2009 Club Internet presented AFK sculpture park, an outdoor sculpture show in Berlin curated by AIDS-3D.

After the clubs

Spike's editors write that the clubs' community "spawned into something now defined as Post-Internet". Van den Dorpel's own path from here runs through Club Internet (2008–2010) and left gallery (2015–2022), alongside museum group shows from 2010 on. The left gallery page reads the continuity (under The line from the surf clubs) as one question about how screen-made work circulates and who can own it; Protocol, Taste, and Systems reads the same years as a move from personal to collective to systemic taste.

See also