Venster — the writing (2024)
Source: Venster (writing, 2024), originally at harm.work/writing/venster. Related works: Markov's Window (2004) and the Venster collection (2024), 100 tokens on Ethereum released with Bright Moments, now also at venster.harm.work.
One frame as a WebKit browser draws it: a lozenge divided into four by four squares, each a gradient from orange to black, on dark grey. By the writing's own account another browser may draw the same file differently.
The collection uses several palettes. Tokens #0, #3, #4 and #5 carry the trait "Palette dream", which adds red and orange to the colours of the Markov's Dream palette first picked for Markov's Window (→ The Markov's Dream Palette).
What the writing says
The text opens in 2006. After art school, "when one couldn't make money with digital art yet", van den Dorpel worked as a web developer for "various smaller and larger startups", where the virtue expected of him was to translate designs "in a 'pixel perfect' manner" that looked the same in every browser, including the "incompatible" Internet Explorer, "that abomination of a browser". He notes that the same expectation of uniformity carries over to art viewed in a browser.
Venster depends on SVG, a W3C standard since 1999. His "admittedly unorthodox use" of it, nested blending modes and filters, renders differently in Chrome, Firefox and Safari "even when I correctly adhere to the documented standard". Restructuring the document so that every browser draws the same thing "required a lot more on-chain calculations", and since the image is calculated by Solidity, "rendering would quickly run out of gas and not display anything at all". He asks whether the artist must answer to the off-chain stack (browser, operating system, screen size, aspect ratio, dark mode) or may prescribe the conditions of display, and answers: "I don't know." He decides "to deem the varying SVG interpretations a feature of the artwork".
The text then sets SVG beside JPG, "superseded by newer image formats", and asks whether support for SVG will one day cease "as it happened to Macromedia Flash not too long ago". It ends: "Perhaps there is not one single canonical rendering, but all are subjective temporal performances of one and the same score."
Where the score / performance distinction went
The writing gives the wiki a term for the on-chain code: the score, which the chain returns identically to every viewer, against the performances that browsers make of it. The distinction was distributed to the pages where it does work:
- The Lozenge — Venster as the 2024 re-making of Markov's Window, with the lozenge as one of its generative roots.
- Process Legibility — leaky abstraction, in Joel Spolsky's sense, extended from the plotter drawing Leaky Abstraction (2025) to the whole off-chain display stack the writing lists.
- Mediation and the Archive — N. Katherine Hayles's flickering signifiers, with cross-browser SVG as an on-chain case. That page's reading score kept, performance let go matches the writing: putting a work on-chain secures the score, while the renderer, browser and screen keep changing the performance. The Flash question at the end of the writing belongs with that page's account of the practice's Flash works.
The explorer site (April 2026)
The screenshot shows the site's filter bar (minted, diagonal split, all feels, high) above a grid of six compositions: tilted squares filled with smaller squares and triangles, in blue, black and white, and green on grey and white grounds.
In April 2026 harm.work announced: "The Venster collection from 2024 has a new home. Besides listing its 100 minted token, the entire seed space can now be explored" (news). The site filters by three traits, root (lozenge, cover, diagonal split), feel (classic, optimistic, melancholic) and complexity (low, medium, high), and a switch moves between the 100 minted tokens and every seed. In the writing's terms the site performs the score for seeds that were never minted, so the work now reaches past its edition.
See also
- The Lozenge — Venster as the re-making of Markov's Window; the lozenge as a generative root
- Process Legibility — leaky abstraction across the display stack
- Mediation and the Archive — flickering signifiers; score kept, performance let go; the Flash works
- The Markov's Dream Palette — the 2004 palette, extended with red and orange in some Venster tokens
- Field (2008/2023) — a Flash animation of 2008 remade on-chain in 2023