Context Switch — Galerie Noah Klink, Berlin (2022)
In the centre hangs Modular Mind (2022), a large light exposure print of nested rounded compartments in pink, violet and olive; it is flanked by two smaller white-framed drawings of dense red and pink line.
The exhibition
Context Switch was a two-person exhibition of Harm van den Dorpel and Achraf Touloub at Galerie Noah Klink, Kulmer Straße 17, Berlin, from 12 November 2022 to 29 January 2023. The title is a computing term: a context switch is the operating system saving the state of one process to run another. Neither text explains why the show took it.
Van den Dorpel showed, per harm.work: the light exposure prints Modular Mind (2022, 107 × 130cm) and Blush Array II (2022, 100 × 130cm); Eventide Paramour (2022, 100 × 100cm, Mutant Garden series); Mutant Garden Autobreeder (2021), a generative animation; the plotter drawing Typographic Trace (2022), with hand retouches in colour pencil; two earlier Automated Drawings, Uttered Modality (2018) and Diaphragm (2018), the gallery's list naming Lazy, Eager, Last, Final (2018) in place of Diaphragm; and Big Pablo Ferenc Zatlas (2021) from Death Imitates Language. Touloub showed watercolour and acrylic on paper and oil on canvas: Discord venue (2020), Sight scenario II (2020), Untitled (electric garden) (2020), The Arrivals III (2021), 1999 (2022) and Egregore rising (2022).
Two texts frame the show: Nora Enning's curatorial essay for the gallery (full text) and Adina Glickstein's Critics' Pick in Artforum (November 2022; full text), which harm.work quotes in Artforum Critics' Picks.
Nora Enning's essay
Enning opens with a study on human connection and longevity (Yang et al., 2016) and with the ancient Greeks, who "identified change as the only constant in life, as everything evolves at all times in relation to each other." Both artists, she writes, explore "generative connections between humans and their surroundings."
Her shared formal point is that neither body of work can be taken in at once: "Observation has always been of the highest sensory demand if one wants to recognize every subtlety. And yet this is impossible in one single glance." Van den Dorpel's "vivid changes in colour and structure … make unchanging observation impossible simply by their design"; Touloub's "repetitive concentration of form, in which one knows how to lose oneself and, in its density, can never fully be grasped" works the same way. Both require "constant movement and change in front of the artworks but one will ultimately fail to comprehend them in their entirety."
Touloub, in her account, "explores concepts of representation as a way to connect to primordial times by creating different figurative motifs to implement concepts of archaic and traditional arts into modern presentation schemes." Of van den Dorpel: "In the age of digitisation, there seems to be no way of not being connected through some digital network. Being invisible nearly becomes impossible, yet one's anonymity remains." His algorithms suggest "a place out of time and space: to find not only one's personal story and viewpoint, but to initiate connections solely out of the mind."
She closes:
To distinguish the digital from the supposedly tangible no longer seems contemporary, as they now seem to complement each other and merge almost seamlessly. The completion and perfection of an artwork are not defined by its material nature. The hierarchy of material-aesthetic reception is deliberately broken up and the work of art is recognized solely as such. What counts even more than the artwork itself is the intention behind it. One cannot only perceive the hapticity or pattern but far more the initial intention as a dematerialised concept – the flux of life.
This is Enning's framing. The wiki's pages on the practice locate the work less in an intention than in a procedure carried out in a particular material: the exposure on photographic paper, the plotter's ink, the colour-pencil retouches on Typographic Trace. Process Legibility relates her paragraph to its distinction between the criterion and the code.
Adina Glickstein in Artforum
Glickstein calls van den Dorpel "an OG in Berlin's cryptoart scene" who "makes software that gives way to colorful sets of nested squircles".
The image is made of overlapping rounded rectangles and capsules, some nested inside others, in pink, violet, olive and grey, with thin outlines and slider-like rows of small bars. The composition is software output, exposed onto photographic paper.
Blush Array II fills its field with a grid of rounded compartments in reds and pinks, crossed by rows of small slider shapes and a horizontal band at mid-height. Of both prints Glickstein writes: "Like snowflakes, Harm van den Dorpel's light exposure prints bear an organic geometry, internally harmonious and each one unique. Like snapshots, their patterns register moments in time, fixed in place by technological means", their "vibrant palettes and soft beveled edges recalling the gentle contours of a user interface" (→ The Squircle).
The photograph shows the work on six square screens hung in a three-by-two grid, each showing magenta and blue compositions of rounded compartments, their cables hanging to the floor. At Noah Klink it ran on an LED screen at the back of the gallery, where Glickstein saw "a grid of infinite, algorithmically generated animations" that "iterates hypnotically". It comes from the same Mutant Garden software as the prints, shown running instead of fixed.
Eventide Paramour is laid out in horizontal bands of repeated motifs (orange half-discs, red dots, outlined circles, rows of capsules) under a top band of grey checkerboard, in orange, grey, black and cream.
In Typographic Trace blue construction lines (circles, arcs and a grid) underlie rounded, letter-like forms drawn over them in black, three in an upper row and denser clusters below.
Of Touloub, Glickstein writes that the title of Egregore Rising "sounds like it could describe the onset of a Twitter swarm, with its gesture toward emergent groupthink", and that Discord Venue "conjures the name of the platform where crypto traders type 'gm' in the chat and seek fresh alpha." His works on paper "are so intricate that they might be described as data-rich, with tight twirls of miniscule petals expanding outward to the borders of the frame."
The greeting is also the title of a work of van den Dorpel's that was not in the show. gm, dated 2017 on harm.work, is a "Photo taken of my screen while reading the Business Insider RSS feed. Cropped to square." The feed's morning item reads "Good morning! Here's what you need to know today." beside a ball of fire; harm.work links the work to a token on Zora.
Her conclusion joins the two:
High-tech as these artworks may well be, they feel—especially in conversation with Touloub's mandala-like illustrations—nothing short of meditative. One artist works in zeroes and ones; the other, in the opposition between line and negative space; mark versus blankness here becomes its own kind of binary code. Against the relentless pace of the doomscroll, both embody a vision of the digital where, mercifully, there's room to breathe.
The two texts together
The two texts start from different places. Enning's essay is about change, connection and the end of the line between digital and tangible; Glickstein's pick is about the cryptoart scene, platform vocabulary and the doomscroll. They meet on one point: both describe work that keeps attention moving without resolving into a single view. Enning says it can never be grasped "in one single glance"; Glickstein calls it meditative, with "room to breathe". Neither connects this to the title, and the wiki does not know why the show was called Context Switch.
See also
- The Squircle — Impure Geometry and the Ideology of Interface — the squircle in the prints
- Process Legibility — Enning's "intention" set against the criterion-and-code distinction
- Evolutionary Logic — the Mutant Garden software behind the prints and the Autobreeder
- Protocol, Taste, and Systems — Enning's change-as-constant frame read against Droitcour's "permanence of change"
- Sculpture and the Object — the digital and the tangible, from the 2012 assemblages to Enning's 2022 essay